The Fine Line Between Content Moderation and Censorship in the Digital Age

Happy Friday! Before diving into the commentary, I want to share a chart posted by Crescat Capital’s Tavi Costa. China, the world’s largest consumer of commodities, just reported record imports of silver at a time when the country is reportedly installing clean energy at the equivalent rate of five large nuclear power plants per week.

Silver is an important component of solar photovoltaic (PV) panels, meaning that for China to reach its ambitious climate targets, it must import massive amounts of the white metal. In June alone, China spent over $228 million on silver, a new monthly record based on Bloomberg data going back to 2009.

Noise with Consequences

Social media has become the place where many of us spend our time, share our lives and, increasingly, get our news. An estimated 12 billion combined hours are spent every day on these platforms, which now host over 5.3 billion unique “identities” or accounts.

number social media users

With scaling like that, misinformation can spread like wildfire. We’ve all seen the headlines, the “fake news” and the deepfakes that make you question your own eyes.

For investors, this isn’t just about the latest gossip. Misinformation (information that’s false or inaccurate) and disinformation (fake news deliberately meant to confuse and deceive) can move markets. A recent study showed a significant correlation between social media interactions and short-term stock market movements.

This isn’t just noise; it’s noise with consequences. Last year, Nationwide Mutual Insurance found that more than a third of non-retired investors aged 18-54 acted on financial information from the internet or social media that turned out to be misleading or incorrect.

Government Overreach in the Age of AI

The rise of artificial intelligence (AI) further complicates matters. We’ve already seen instances of AI-generated images causing market jitters, such as when someone posted fake images of an explosion near the Pentagon last year. As AI technology advances, distinguishing fact from fiction will become increasingly challenging.

Given these challenges, it’s no surprise that Americans are expressing a historic lack of confidence in news media and issuing calls for increased regulation of online content.

no confidence in media

However, we must be extremely cautious about how we approach this issue. Governments, in their wisdom or perhaps in their panic, have decided to step in, and they’re not just playing referee… They’re threatening to be the players, coaches and umpires all at once.