Should You Worry About the Safety of Schwab Accounts?
Advisor Perspectives welcomes guest contributions. The views presented here do not necessarily represent those of Advisor Perspectives.
I wrote the following letter to IMA clients, but I suspect some of you may find it of interest as you may have accounts at Charles Schwab, Fidelity, or TD Ameritrade.
Many investors, including my clients, have been worried about their Schwab account safety. Are they right to be worried?
My firm, IMA, is sending this email to all our clients. We could have sent it only to those who have money in IMA accounts at Schwab, but in many cases our clients have assets outside of IMA management. Also, though this letter focuses on Schwab, I address TD and Fidelity as well.
I have received a few inquiries from clients expressing their concern about the safety of their money at Charles Schwab. Schwab has been in the news because the banking side of the business made investments into high-quality, long-term bonds whose prices have declined as interest rates have risen.
I could go into a very detailed analysis of Charles Schwab, but I won’t waste your time. The situation is fluid; interest rates can rise, worsening the losses, and deposits can outflow a lot more, deepening the losses further.
I have to be honest; anything I say below this paragraph is a waste of your time. If there is an institution too big to fail, it is Schwab, which has over $7 trillion in assets. If Schwab goes bankrupt and even a single account holder’s money is affected, we will have no economy or stock market. It is that simple. Account holders losing their money would be like dropping a nuclear bomb on the U.S. economy. Investors losing money on the cash at Schwab would create a run on the bank (actually on the economy) like the world has never seen. Schwab’s problems are less severe than those of many other banks, and if necessary the U.S. government will bail out its depositors.
However, for those of you who have some extra time, or maybe just continue reading because you enjoy my writing, here are a few more reasons not to worry.
Your stocks, bonds, and money market funds are registered in your name. For example, shares of Philip Morris or Schwab Treasury Obligations Money Fund (SNOXX) are database entries in your name. Any securities, other than cash, are on Schwab’s custodial side of the business, belong to you, and cannot be taken away from you, even if Schwab was to go bankrupt.
Cash, which is on the bank side of the business, has several layers of insurance. It is FDIC insured up to $500,000 per account registration; IRAs are counted separately from personal accounts, etc. There is also SIPC insurance of $500,000 ($250,000 counted towards cash). Additionally, Schwab has extra insurance that covers cash up to $1.15 million per customer. For more information, please see links at the bottom.
We are striving to keep as little money in pure cash as possible. Most of your cash is in the money market, which, as I mentioned above, is on the custodial (non-bank) side of the business.
All my and my family’s investable assets are at Schwab and TD Ameritrade. Lately, I have been losing sleep over my chess game (which is getting worse), but not Schwab’s liquidity. Unfortunately, unlike Schwab, I am not too big to lose.
Regarding TD and Fidelity:
TD Ameritrade, merging with Charles Schwab later this year, is both FDIC and SIPC insured. At TD, we minimize the amount of real cash in your accounts by purchasing money market funds which invest in short-duration US Treasuries.
For clients with accounts at Fidelity; it does not have a bank. It is not exposed to the same type of risks as Schwab. Fidelity is also SIPC insured, with additional SIPC insurance covering cash up to $1.9 million per customer.
Here are a few more links for your reference:
IMA clients based outside of the US require a slightly different approach to ensure airtight safety of cash and securities.
International clients at all custodians are not eligible for purchase of money market mutual funds, nor are cash balances FDIC insured. However, these accounts are still SIPC insured for securities, and this coverage also extends to cash balances in accounts up to $1.15m and $1.9m at Schwab and Fidelity, respectively.
Further, because we cannot buy money market mutual funds the same way as for domestic clients, we will start purchasing a money market ETF (SGOV) that invests in short-term U.S. Treasury securities.
Vitaliy Katsenelson, CFA is CEO of IMA – a value investing firm in Denver.
How can you safely invest in a market this speculative? Check out his free series on The 6 Commandments of Value Investing.
Or for something more down-to-earth, check out Soul in the Game: a book of inspiring stories and hardwon lessons on how to live a meaningful life, drawn from classical composers, ancient stoics, and contemporary thinkers.