As rocket builders around the world struggle to match the low-cost launch capabilities of Elon Musk’s SpaceX, the controversial billionaire just raised the bar. His competitors won’t be the only ones worried.
In a historic first, SpaceX on Saturday used a pair of giant mechanical arms to catch the new Starship spacecraft after it had blasted into orbit and delivered 26 satellites. The capture of the first-stage rocket booster was aborted, but SpaceX has made this less-complex maneuver three times already. Starship’s retrieval paves the way for regular flights at dramatically lower costs once the company perfects catching both stages of the rocket for rapid reuse. This will see SpaceX revolutionize space travel for a second time, after its Falcon 9 slashed launch costs by 90%, even though it only recycles the booster.
SpaceX’s monumental achievement puts the US well ahead of China in the space race. But it’s something of a double-edged sword for NASA and the Defense Department. Their dependence on the company to carry satellites and other hardware into space is likely to grow at a time when Musk’s dealings with the government will be heavily scrutinized by Democrats, who take control of Congress. For legislators, the dilemma is how to dilute Musk’s dominance in the industry without throttling the innovative energy SpaceX has unleashed.
Read more: Nvidia After Jensen Huang – What Leadership Change Means for Investors
It’s risky for the two agencies to have one main avenue to reach space and important for the federal government to support the development of other launch companies to catch up with SpaceX. But history shows that this is no easy feat . And let’s not forgot that SpaceX is the only reason the US maintains a lead over China. The Asian nation successfully recaptured the first-stage booster of a rocket in July — about 11 years after Falcon 9.
Democrats in Congress are sure to investigate Musk for his cozy relationship with the administration of President Donald Trump. The power shift would be even greater if a Democrat wins the next presidential election and controls key regulators such as NASA and the Federal Aviation Administration. Musk did himself no favors by heading the Department of Government Efficiency, which was created to cut government waste, but fell far short of its own stated goals .
Congress also will scrutinize how SpaceX interacts with Starshield, the military- controlled space-based internet service that the company sells to the Defense Department. And it will want answers about who ordered slowdowns in Starshield and the commercial Starlink satellite services in Ukraine, which are used to beat back Russian attacks. The incidents have raised alarm among European allies about their own dependence on SpaceX .
But critics should keep in mind that Ukraine would be digitally blind without Starlink, and Musk has extended other support such as denying Russian forces use of the network at the behest of Ukraine’s defense minister.
Congressional oversight is necessary, given SpaceX’s central role in the federal government’s space programs, especially for defense. But the investigative zeal of the new Democratic Congress shouldn’t seek to undercut Musk’s space ambitions as part of a revenge tour for his support of Republicans.
Until another company can match the efficiency of Falcon 9, the government will continue to lean heavily on SpaceX, especially for programs like the Golden Dome space defense network and the national-security imperative to be the first nation to build a permanent moon base. To maintain its lead, the US needs SpaceX to set the pace in space, while supporting competitors to catch up.
The conundrum is that developing reusable rockets, spacecraft and satellites is extremely hard and doesn’t depend only on government contracts or money. Boeing initially was given more funding than SpaceX to develop a spacecraft that would take astronauts to the International Space Station and break the dependence on Russian rockets after the Space Shuttle program was retired in 2011.
Boeing’s Starliner launched one two-person crew to the ISS in 2024 but had engine problems, and the astronauts were taken home in SpaceX’s Dragon capsule. Dragon has flown 13 crewed operational missions to the ISS starting in 2020, and another is scheduled for March. Starliner might resume crewed missions in 2028 if it performs well on test missions. The third company awarded a contract to take crews to the ISS, Sierra Nevada Corp., floundered.
Just think, NASA would still need Russia to carry astronauts to the ISS if it weren’t for SpaceX. That’s something to keep in mind as legislators sharpen their knives.
Similarly, billionaire Jeff Bezos founded Blue Origin two years before SpaceX and has sunk $30 billion into the venture, but its New Glenn rocket has only launched into orbit twice. It’s unclear what the US government can do to overcome the technological hurdles that have slowed down legacy launchers such as Boeing and startups including Blue Origin and Rocket Lab, which is scheduled to launch its partially reuseable Neutron rocket next.
SpaceX shouldn’t be seen as a threat. To the contrary, the company is paving the way for a vibrant commercial space industry by lowering the cost to access space, and spurring ideas on things such as improved weather monitoring, orbital data centers or even manufacturing pharmaceuticals at zero gravity.
It’s also lowering the taxpayer cost for national defense as space becomes the new battleground . China is on its way to beginning regular flights of partially reusable rockets, which will speed the building of its two networks in low-earth orbit — Guowang and Qianfan — that combined have about 500 satellites and will eventually rival Starlink.
Emotions from the midterm elections are still raw and there’s a temptation to want to rein in SpaceX or even take it down. This wouldn’t be helpful for the US and its allies, but it sure would make China’s leadership ecstatic.
A message from Advisor Perspectives and VettaFi: Discover something new! Click here to register for our upcoming webcasts.
Bloomberg News provided this article. For more articles like this please visit
bloomberg.com.
More Innovative ETFs Topics >