The Trouble With One-and-Done Financial Solutions

rick kahlerAdvisor Perspectives welcomes guest contributions. The views presented here do not necessarily represent those of Advisor Perspectives.

Sometimes the solution to a money problem seems to be a one-and-done fix. Maybe you’re having trouble paying bills and are accumulating debt. Then you receive an unexpected tax refund, get a raise, or refinance your mortgage, so everything should be better. Each of those can help, but none of them by itself changes the underlying patterns that caused the problem.

A debt consolidation loan is a clear example. It may provide lower rates and payments that offer a respite. Yet the relief may not last. A 2023 study by TransUnion, titled “Debt Consolidation in a Rising Economy,” found that people who used a personal loan to pay off credit cards cut their card balances by 57% on average. For many, the balances were nearly back to their earlier levels 18 months later. The loan could not change the circumstances and the spending that built the debt in the first place.

In my podcast interview with Olena Keshysheva, a certified financial planner in Canada who practices financial therapy, she drew a line between two forms of change that people mix up. One she calls healing, which is what happens when someone breaks an arm, comes down with an illness, or even suffers a great loss like a natural disaster or a death in the family. Whether the incident is large or small, there is something specific to recover from. The other is what she calls evolution, a gradual process that happens over time.

Changing most money habits requires the second kind of recovery. A pattern that took years to build rarely changes in a single event, even one that does a great deal to solve an immediate problem. Olena says, “The transformation happens over a lifetime.”