Why Energy Still Looks Cheap

Russ discusses why energy, despite rallying – and outperforming -- this year, still looks like a value.

The S&P 500 Index rose roughly 8% in January, the best start to a year since 1987. Despite the magnitude of the rally, the S&P 500 Energy Sector has outperformed by more than 5%. As impressive as the gains have been, January’s rally still leaves the sector below where it started December.

When I last highlighted energy stocks in mid-November I focused on the discrepancy between the sector’s valuation and oil prices. Shortly after both the sector and the commodity promptly plunged: Between mid-November and the Christmas Eve low the S&P 500 Energy Sector Index dropped more than 20%, having already lost about 14% from the October high. As a result, despite the magnitude of the recent gains the sector remains cheap. Consider the following:

  1. The energy sector closed January at 1.7 times price-to-book (P/B) value. While this is roughly 10% above December’s multi-decade low, current valuations are still below the depressed levels witnessed in November and in the bottom 10% of historical observations.
  2. On a relative basis U.S. energy companies continue to trade at the largest discount to the broader market since at least 1995. The P/B on the sector is about 50% of the broader market’s (see Chart 1).S&P Energy Sector Relative Value
  3. As discussed last November, energy is not only cheap versus the broader market but also relative to the price of oil. Historically, the price of oil has explained roughly 20% of the variation in the relative multiple of the sector. At $54/barrel, crude oil prices suggest the sector should be trading at an 18-20% discount to the market, not a nearly 50% discount.

The dollar matters

One potential explanation for the magnitude of the recent discount: the dollar. A stronger dollar has historically been associated with lower relative valuations. Since 1995, the relative P/B of the energy sector has been approximately 10% higher when the Dollar Index (DXY) is lower year-over-year versus times when the dollar is higher. This relationship is arguably a function of several factors. A weaker dollar is supportive of commodity prices, which are generally denominated in dollars, as well as representing a de facto monetary easing.