What Could Move the Markets Next?

Markets are not too expensive, or too cheap. As Russ explains, that offers a clue into what could cause the next move.

Stock markets have been more wobbly of late. While the proximate cause was an unexpected deterioration (collapse?) in trade talks with China, many investors were getting nervous even before the most recent barrage of tweets. Some were understandably skeptical of a rally that took U.S. equity indexes up 25% in four months. The skepticism was further compounded by the fact that the rally was entirely driven by multiple expansion, i.e. paying more for a dollar of earnings.

Given this dynamic, and apart from any trade risks, have stocks simply become too expensive? Surprisingly, the answer is not necessarily.

The S&P 500 Index is currently trading at roughly 17 times next year’s earnings (as measured by price-to-earnings ratio, or P/E) and a little under 19 times trailing earnings. Today’s valuation is high but not extreme. The P/E on the S&P 500 is slightly above the post-crisis average and modestly above the long-term average. That said, today’s valuation is roughly 20% below the January 2018 peak and roughly 35% below the 1999 top.

Valuations in comparison to market conditions

More importantly, how do today’s valuations compare against market conditions? As I’ve discussed in the past, valuation is conditional on the environment. Investors may be more or less willing to pay up for stocks depending on financial conditions, growth expectations and inflation. Looking across six different models, which on average explain about 40% of the variation in multiples, current valuations look about right.

Going into a bit more detail, stocks look most expensive based on the level of economic growth relative to expectations, i.e. economic surprise indexes. To the extent U.S. economic data has generally been trailing expectations, you would expect stocks to trade about 10% cheaper than they currently are.

Conversely, relative to consumer confidence, one of the better coincident factors in the post-crisis regime, stock valuations look about 10% too cheap. Most of the other metrics, which are primarily different versions of financial conditions, suggest that the P/E on the S&P 500 is almost exactly where you would expect it to be (see Chart).