The Fed Cut Rates; Will it Be Déjà Vu All Over Again?

As expected, the Federal Reserve (Fed) cut interest rates last week to take the fed funds rate down to 4.25% (upper bound). Moreover, through the release of the updated dot-plot, the Committee signaled that two more interest rate cuts could be appropriate this year, which would take the fed funds rate down to 3.75% (upper bound). The cut was the first rate reduction since last December and the continuation of the rate-cutting campaign that began last September, which has so far seen an unusual reaction out of the Treasury market.

When the Fed delivered its first 50 basis point rate cut last September, bond markets responded in a way that defied four decades of precedent. Instead of falling as expected, the 10-year Treasury yield surged, creating one of the most counterintuitive market moves in recent memory. The progression was relentless: 45.5 basis points higher after 25 days, 78.6 basis points after 50 days, and 93.7 basis points after 100 days. The 10-year Treasury yield ultimately rose by over 100 basis points from its then September lows.

This move was remarkable not just for its magnitude, but for breaking historical patterns. In the previous five Fed cutting cycles dating back to the 1980s, the 10-year Treasury yield declined, on average by nearly 1% within 100 days of the first rate cut. Part of the explanation lies in how aggressively markets had positioned for cuts before the Fed acted. By September 2024, markets had priced in 10 rate cuts before the end of 2025 — a level of easing that proved wildly optimistic. When slowing economic conditions fell short of these extreme expectations, bonds sold off sharply.

Markets Priced In 10 Rate Cuts Before the Fed Cut Once

Markets Priced In 10 Rate Cuts Before the Fed Cut Once