Productivity: Earning Our Keep

Better productivity is easing employers' burden of higher wages.

In our writing and speaking, we try to strike a balance that shows we understand a variety of perspectives. This is easier for some topics than others.

Wages can be a particularly difficult subject on which to strike a balance. From the worker’s perspective, who wouldn’t want to get a raise? It’s a reward for good work and enables a better quality of life. But from the employer’s side, higher wages are a greater cost that can impact profit margins. Economically, higher incomes bode well for consumption. However, when workers see rapid wage gains, the risk of a wage-price spiral emerges: better pay fuels more consumption, driving up prices, and leading workers to demand further raises.

We have thus watched trends in hourly earnings closely through this inflationary cycle. They followed a similar path as most measures of inflation: from a peak of a 5.9% annual gain in March 2022, they have cooled, most recently to 4.4%. The current rate is higher than the former norm, and the normalization has stalled; in the pre-pandemic cycle, wage gains peaked at 3.6%.

Fortunately, higher compensation is not always inflationary. Workers’ pay should reflect their output. More productive workers are more valuable. In a well-functioning labor market, they will receive higher pay. The latest measures of productivity suggest this stage of the cycle has commenced, calming some of our worst fears of the inflationary effects of higher wages.

Second quarter U.S. productivity data showed an encouraging slowdown in unit labor costs (ULC): the measure of what employers pay for the output they receive from their employees. Compensation is still growing at a steady rate, but output increased. In effect, employers are getting more bang for their payroll buck.

Productivity tends to follow a pattern in economic cycles. As a recession begins and workers are laid off, the remaining workers maintain output, boosting productivity. Then, lower demand leads to lower output, and productivity declines with it. In this cycle, the pattern played out swiftly. Productivity was also challenged by the “great resignation:” Experienced workers changed jobs or retired, and new hires needed time to reach their potential. Now, as the labor market settles into a state of lower turnover, employers are seeing some upside in better productivity.

Unit Labor Cost