Measuring, anticipating and controlling the cost of healthcare are all difficult.
I have become more acutely aware of health care costs as the frequency of my visits to clinicians and laboratories has increased. A basic blood workup takes the technician five minutes to initiate and is analyzed by machines. The overall bill: $1,200.
Fortunately for us, insurance covers a significant fraction of this total. But I have periodically wondered how statisticians measure inflation for medical services. Health care is big business in the United States, accounting for 15.7% of personal consumption expenditures (PCE). This is the weight assigned to the sector in the PCE deflator, the Federal Reserve’s favored inflation gauge.
Health care is a much smaller component of the consumer price index (CPI), accounting for just 7.8% of the total. The difference in weights between the two inflation gauges exists because the CPI measures only the costs paid by households (inclusive of insurance premiums), while the PCE deflator includes costs paid on behalf of households by insurers.
The two approaches produce significantly different paths of health care inflation. The CPI for health care shows considerable amplitude, while the PCE component is steadier. This is due to changing insurance coverage from providers and the selection of different coverage by consumers.
On a year-over-year basis, medical costs in the CPI have declined, contributing to the moderation seen in the overall index. The main contributor is a 30% drop in the CPI’s gauge of health insurance premiums. This is highly counterintuitive, and raises questions about the calculations.