Don’t Fight the Tape. The Market Is on Small Caps.

Sometimes the market simply wants to latch onto a good story. There are several making the rounds this summer.

The big one is the spike in the small-cap Russell 2000 since the release of the latest Consumer Price Index (CPI) report, which shocked the market by printing 0.0% month-over-month in June. According to Bloomberg’s John Authers, the 11.5% pop in that index in the first five sessions after the CPI release was only exceeded by spikes witnessed amid the crises of “(the 1998 collapse of hedge fund) Long-Term Capital Management, Dot-Com, the Global Financial Crisis, the 2011 U.S. debt downgrade and the pandemic.”

A wide assortment of balance sheets can be found across small caps, ranging from rock solid fortresses to companies knocking on the doors of bankruptcy court. No matter. The market wishes to paint U.S. small caps with a broad brush, one that has them receiving much-needed respite on their variable rate debt while fixed-rate large caps see no immediate benefit.

How large is the fixed versus floating debt discrepancy up and down the market cap spectrum? At year-end, about 30% of small caps’ debt was variable rate, while the proportion for large caps was 8%, according to Voya. But to hear the market chatter, you would think the proportions are 100% and 0%.

Because of this perception about their susceptibility to short-term interest rate oscillations, the market is buying small caps on the floating rate theme amid the scramble to price in near certainty that the Federal Reserve (Fed) will cut rates at its September 18 meeting.

Whether lopping 25 or 50 or 75 basis points (bps) from small caps’ cost of debt truly moves the needle is not what matters. What matters is the bull market is finding more winners now and attaching the stories to fit the case, as it always does.