Diversification Now an Active Decision

Diversification Now an Active Decision

Key takeaways

  • Rising concentration and overlapping holdings across styles can leave seemingly diversified portfolios dependent on the same handful of mega-cap companies.
  • In our view, genuine diversification requires looking at the underlying companies, position sizes and shared investment themes across an entire portfolio.
  • Deliberate security selection and limits on company and thematic exposure can enable active managers to provide the breadth that concentrated benchmarks and the passive vehicles that track them increasingly lack.

Over the last three decades, investors have gravitated toward passive investment products for broad equity market exposure. Active products have been used as supplements, to express a deliberate view or obtain idiosyncratic exposure. This approach rests on the assumption that the passive index products are diversified; that is no longer the case. The S&P 500 Index, the Russell 1000 Growth Index and the Russell 1000 Value Index—among the most widely used benchmarks in the United States—have all become concentrated (Exhibit 1). Moreover, the indexes no longer look different, they have converged on the same companies.

Because success breeds complacency, and because the markets have done so well for so long, most investors seem to be overlooking this risk. Allocating 50% to the S&P 500, 30% to the Russell 1000 Growth and 20% to the Russell 1000 Value, for example, yields a portfolio where just five companies tied to the single theme of artificial intelligence (AI)—Nvidia, Apple, Alphabet, Microsoft and Amazon—represent 31% of the total portfolio.

Exhibit 1: Top 10 Index Constituents Over Time

See more: How to Build a Bond Portfolio

Index Investing Ain’t What It Used To Be

The S&P 500 Index is the archetype for a broad market index. Yet four companies—Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft and Alphabet—now account for 27% of the benchmark. It takes just 20 companies to account for half the index weight by market cap.1 Nvidia, on its own, is larger than the energy, utilities and real estate sectors combined; Nvidia, Apple and Microsoft together outweigh six of the index’s 11 sectors combined.2

Today, the 10 largest holdings represent 40.6% of the S&P 500 (Exhibit 2). For context, that figure hovered around 20% for most of the last 35 years, breaching 25% only at the height of the dot-com bubble before rising sharply beginning in 2020.

Exhibit 2: Top 10 Holdings in S&P 500, 1990-2026

Growth stocks are even less diversified. In the Russell 1000 Growth, two companies—Nvidia and Alphabet—make up a quarter of the index and seven make up half.3 The top 10 make up 60.5%. Nvidia alone is 15.7%—roughly one dollar in six. Approximately a third of the index is semiconductors, which have grown in weight dramatically here as they have in the S&P 500 (Exhibit 3).

Exhibit 3: Semiconductor Weight in S&P 500 and Russell 1000 Growth