Municipal vs. Corporate Bonds: How to Decide?

two-paths

Key takeaways

  • Municipal bonds and investment-grade corporate bonds are two types of fixed income investments that can be part of an investors' core fixed income allocation, but deciding between the two depends on multiple factors. We suggest starting with the type of account you're using. Municipal bonds generally make more sense in taxable accounts, while corporate bonds generally make more sense in tax-deferred accounts, like an IRA or 401(k), because they usually pay higher yields.
  • In a taxable account, your tax rate is the primary factor. If your total tax rate is above the current "breakeven" rate of about 37%, municipal bonds will likely yield more after taxes; if it's below, corporate bonds will likely make more sense.
  • Credit quality and maturity matter, too. Munis offer more AAA and AA rated options and have historically defaulted less than corporates, but for lower-rated and longer-maturity bonds, which one yields more after taxes will depend on your tax bracket.

How do you choose between corporate and municipal bonds? Both have characteristics that can be useful in your portfolio, depending on your goals and circumstances, but they're not right for every situation.

See more: Sticking With the Broadening Call

First, we suggest starting with the type of account you're using:

  • Interest income from municipal bonds is generally exempt from federal and potentially state income taxes, so munis can make more sense than corporate bonds in taxable accounts, like a brokerage account, but it will depend on a few factors we'll discuss below.
  • For tax-deferred accounts, such as an individual retirement account (IRA) or 401(k), corporate bonds generally make more sense because they usually pay higher yields in exchange for the lack of tax benefits that munis usually offer.

Beyond that, you should be aware of factors such as yields, maturity, and credit quality, as they can differ between the two types of bonds and influence which is more attractive. Here's what you should consider when deciding between investment-grade municipal and corporate bonds.